Appendix A — what HALFWAY actually cost (reconciled)

Generated by docs/curriculum/appendix_a.py from production/phase2/ledger.csv and production/phase3/ledger.csv. Unique jobs only; refunded jobs carry 0; unknowns are marked, never estimated into the totals.

A.1 Credits consumed, by job type

Job type Unique charged jobs Credits Seconds bought (parsed) Note
Seedance 2.0 (video, 720p) 76 2718.00 466 s from 58 of 76 jobs
Nano Banana Pro (image) 16 32.00
Seedance 2.5 Edit (video edit) 1 26.00
TTS (audio) 44 6.71
Voice Change (audio) 2 3.00
Phase 2 images with a credit figure in the note 5 10.00 Soul Cinema / NBP sheets, 2026-09-10/11
Phase 2 images without a figure 16 unknown Soul Cinema 0.125–0.25 and NBP 2 per image at the time; not summed
Phase 2 NBP 'Unlimited' images 36 0 free through Sep 17 under the plan; the biggest single saving
Phase 3 NBP rows at 0 credits (Unlimited or unpriced) 161 0 includes queue/done duplicates; not deduplicated because unpriced

Phase 3 unique charged jobs: 139, credits 2785.71. Phase 2 known: 10.00. Ledger total (known): 2795.71.

A.2 Reconciliation against the account

Check Value Source
Plan 3000 credits/month (Ultra), balance 3008 on 2026-09-10 HIGGSFIELD-PLAN-2026-09-10.md row 0.10
Balance at the end 200.29 on 2026-09-16 phase3 ledger, account API read
Consumed by balance 2807.71 subtraction
Ledger known total 2795.71 A.1
Gap 12.00 phase 2 images without a figure (16 jobs at 0.125–2 each) plus rounding; unknown, not estimated
Platform project page 2581 credits, 205 generations, read 2026-09-16 ~17:45 PDT public project page
Ledger video+image 2776.00 A.1
Difference vs project page not explained the page counter's basis is not documented; unknown

Platform jobs export (authoritative per-job cost, read 2026-09-16 ~18:25 PDT through the platform's paginated jobs API, 55 pages, cost field in centi-credits):

Job type status jobs credits
seedance_2_0 completed 78 2754.00
nano_banana_2 completed 124 46.00
seedance_2_0 failed 1 27.00
seedance_2_5 nsfw 1 26.00
text2speech_v2 completed 42 6.60
voice_change_merge completed 2 3.00
text2speech_v2 failed 1 0.15
seed_audio completed 1 0.10
qwen_audio_tts completed 1 0.01
nano_banana_2 nsfw 4 0.00
nano_banana_2 failed 1 0.00
hf_mult_motion_control completed 1 0.00
soul_cinematic completed 16 0.00
Check Value
Completed jobs, platform cost 2809.71
Failed / nsfw jobs, platform cost field (refunded per ledger) 53.15
Consumed by balance 2807.71
Platform completed − balance +2.00 (rounding of the 2026-09-10 balance read)
Ledger known − platform completed -14.00 (ledger misses 2 Seedance jobs and a few charged NBP jobs it recorded as Unlimited; the platform export is the number to publish)
Jobs in the project 273 (78 completed Seedance, 124 completed NBP, 16 Soul Cinema at 0) vs project page 205 generations

Refunded / failed jobs recorded (0 credits kept): - 5A 7: 6 s test of v17 (shots/5A/tests/v17_test6s_fence.txt): L1 wording + L2 led turn + v2 opaque sheet, Blender ref - plate_car_s6_green 1: job 00d023e0 status failed after ~20 min in_progress (queued ~4 min first); tile: Failed / Credits refunded; n - 1A-start rebuild-v3: UI NSFW / Restricted content detected / Credits refunded. No output image. Submitted Unlimited so no debit/ref - 1B sync-edit-v1: UI Input may contain a real person or public figure; Credits refunded. Source was generatedHiggsfield1B not re - 4D laugh-rock-A: Script [laughs] alone rejected by platform (job 4cd69b32 status failed). Price read 0.15 before the click; ref

A.3 Cash, local compute, labour

Category Value Source
Cash one Ultra plan month; the price paid was not recorded in the ledgers → unknown here; the list price of that plan as of 2026-09-22 is in A.5; no top-up (Director rule) HIGGSFIELD-PLAN row 0.10; Director rules
Local compute brain (2× RTX 3090): Wan pass Sep 8–10 (59 takes, one GPU died), MusicGen score Sep 16; hours not metered → unknown BRAIN-PASS-2026-09-08.md, SCORE-PLAN.md
Labour Director review rounds and agent sessions; not metered → unknown; the git log (Aug 13 → Sep 16, ~570 commits) is the only trace git log

A.4 The Chapter 6 worksheet (v5: Chapter C), filled with HALFWAY

Row HALFWAY value How derived
Cards in the shotlist 39 shot families received at least one paid video job (masters and tests included) phase3 ledger, Seedance jobs grouped by shot id
Hero video jobs 76 unique charged Seedance jobs
Retake share 18 of 39 families had ≥2 jobs = 46% same
Test / stress / proof video jobs 12 jobs, 398 credits note or settings mention test/stress/proof/arm
Seconds bought (parsed) 466 s over 58 jobs; all 76 jobs ≈ 604 s at 4.5/s settings field; credits ÷ rate for the rest
Usable generated seconds in the final cut 174.2 s CUT33 manifest, excluding title/credits/packshot
Trim loss 1 − 174/604 ≈ 71% of bought seconds not in the film the two rows above; includes tests and rejected takes
Image jobs 16 charged NBP + 161 unpriced NBP rows + phase 2 57 ledgers
Audio jobs 44 TTS + 2 voice change, 9.71 credits ledgers
Rewrite reserve actually used ring scene recut into one shot (6B-lift dropped), 7A2 removed, 5A far-earring and 5C stubble retakes, final 8A added build_cutNN docstrings, ledger decisions
Time not metered; Sep 10 → Sep 16 for phase 3 git log
Stop threshold never written down before the first spend; the closest was the Director's 'no top-up' rule Director rules

Validation: the worksheet rows above reproduce the A.1 video total by construction (same rows). What the worksheet could not have predicted in advance: the 71 % trim loss and the 46 % retake share. Those two numbers are the point of the appendix.

A.5 Plan prices on four platforms, as read on 2026-09-22

Read 2026-09-22T20:39Z to 20:55Z from each public pricing page, signed out (the receipt is plan-prices-2026-09-22.json beside this file). Prices exclude tax; every page says so or is silent. Ours was made on Higgsfield because the festival lived there; nothing in the process needs it. Two of the four are Chinese; both keep their plan tables behind a login, so only what a signed-out page shows is here, and the rest is unknown, not estimated. Prices change; re-read before you budget (Chapter 6).

Platform Plan Credits / month USD / month, monthly USD / month, billed annually Page note
Higgsfield Starter 270 19 19 page: 'No difference compared to monthly'; '~15 Seedance 2.0 Fast videos'
Higgsfield Plus 1,200 59 47 '~53 Seedance 2.0 videos'
Higgsfield Ultra (3,000 tier; 6,000 and 9,000 tiers exist, not read) 3,000 129 99 '~133 Seedance 2.0 videos'; the plan HALFWAY was made on
Runway Standard 625 15 12
Runway Pro 2,250 35 28
Runway Max 9,500 95 76 credits roll over one month
Kling AI Standard 660 10 (then 8.8 after a 12 % monthly discount; first month 6.99) not read page: '100 Credits = $1.06'
Kling AI Pro 3,000 37 (then 32.56 after a 12 % monthly discount; first month 25.99) not read '100 Credits = $0.87'
Kling AI Premier 8,000 92 (then 80.96 after a 12 % monthly discount; first month 64.99) not read '100 Credits = $0.81'
Kling AI Ultra 26,000 180 (then 159.99 after a 12 % monthly discount; first month 127.99) not read '100 Credits = $0.49'
Jimeng (即梦) / Dreamina plans behind login unknown unknown unknown signed-out page shows only: "中秋礼遇
Hailuo (海螺) / MiniMax plans behind login unknown unknown unknown signed-out page shows only: "From $9.99/mo"

Cost of one generated second, where a page gives both numbers. Dollars per second = (USD per month, monthly) ÷ (credits per month) × (credits per second of the named job). Only rows whose two inputs are on the page or in our ledger are computed; resolution and model differ across rows, so this compares what each platform charges, not what you get.

Platform, plan Job Credits / s USD / credit USD / s Source of credits / s
Higgsfield, Ultra Seedance 2.0, 720p, 8 s 4.5 129 ÷ 3,000 = 0.0430 0.193 GENERATE button read 2026-09-10 (HIGGSFIELD-PLAN-2026-09-10.md:88), not on today's pricing page
Runway, Pro Gen-4.5, 5 s 12 35 ÷ 2,250 = 0.0156 0.187 compare table on the page
Runway, Pro Seedance 2.0 Pro 1080p, 4 s 40 35 ÷ 2,250 = 0.0156 0.622 compare table on the page
Runway, Pro Seedance 2.0 Fast, 4 s 29 35 ÷ 2,250 = 0.0156 0.451 compare table on the page
Kling AI any video unknown — unknown not on the membership page; shown at the generate button after sign-in
Jimeng (即梦) / Dreamina Seedance 2.5 720p, promotional first-month floor not read not read ¥0.28 / s (CNY, promotional, first month) banner, signed out; the plan table needs a Chinese login and was not read