Appendix A — what HALFWAY actually cost (reconciled)
Generated by docs/curriculum/appendix_a.py from production/phase2/ledger.csv and production/phase3/ledger.csv. Unique jobs only; refunded jobs carry 0; unknowns are marked, never estimated into the totals.
A.1 Credits consumed, by job type
| Job type |
Unique charged jobs |
Credits |
Seconds bought (parsed) |
Note |
| Seedance 2.0 (video, 720p) |
76 |
2718.00 |
466 s from 58 of 76 jobs |
|
| Nano Banana Pro (image) |
16 |
32.00 |
|
|
| Seedance 2.5 Edit (video edit) |
1 |
26.00 |
|
|
| TTS (audio) |
44 |
6.71 |
|
|
| Voice Change (audio) |
2 |
3.00 |
|
|
| Phase 2 images with a credit figure in the note |
5 |
10.00 |
|
Soul Cinema / NBP sheets, 2026-09-10/11 |
| Phase 2 images without a figure |
16 |
unknown |
|
Soul Cinema 0.125–0.25 and NBP 2 per image at the time; not summed |
| Phase 2 NBP 'Unlimited' images |
36 |
0 |
|
free through Sep 17 under the plan; the biggest single saving |
| Phase 3 NBP rows at 0 credits (Unlimited or unpriced) |
161 |
0 |
|
includes queue/done duplicates; not deduplicated because unpriced |
Phase 3 unique charged jobs: 139, credits 2785.71. Phase 2 known: 10.00. Ledger total (known): 2795.71.
A.2 Reconciliation against the account
| Check |
Value |
Source |
| Plan |
3000 credits/month (Ultra), balance 3008 on 2026-09-10 |
HIGGSFIELD-PLAN-2026-09-10.md row 0.10 |
| Balance at the end |
200.29 on 2026-09-16 |
phase3 ledger, account API read |
| Consumed by balance |
2807.71 |
subtraction |
| Ledger known total |
2795.71 |
A.1 |
| Gap |
12.00 |
phase 2 images without a figure (16 jobs at 0.125–2 each) plus rounding; unknown, not estimated |
| Platform project page |
2581 credits, 205 generations, read 2026-09-16 ~17:45 PDT |
public project page |
| Ledger video+image |
2776.00 |
A.1 |
| Difference vs project page |
not explained |
the page counter's basis is not documented; unknown |
Platform jobs export (authoritative per-job cost, read 2026-09-16 ~18:25 PDT through the platform's paginated jobs API, 55 pages, cost field in centi-credits):
| Job type |
status |
jobs |
credits |
| seedance_2_0 |
completed |
78 |
2754.00 |
| nano_banana_2 |
completed |
124 |
46.00 |
| seedance_2_0 |
failed |
1 |
27.00 |
| seedance_2_5 |
nsfw |
1 |
26.00 |
| text2speech_v2 |
completed |
42 |
6.60 |
| voice_change_merge |
completed |
2 |
3.00 |
| text2speech_v2 |
failed |
1 |
0.15 |
| seed_audio |
completed |
1 |
0.10 |
| qwen_audio_tts |
completed |
1 |
0.01 |
| nano_banana_2 |
nsfw |
4 |
0.00 |
| nano_banana_2 |
failed |
1 |
0.00 |
| hf_mult_motion_control |
completed |
1 |
0.00 |
| soul_cinematic |
completed |
16 |
0.00 |
| Check |
Value |
| Completed jobs, platform cost |
2809.71 |
| Failed / nsfw jobs, platform cost field (refunded per ledger) |
53.15 |
| Consumed by balance |
2807.71 |
| Platform completed − balance |
+2.00 (rounding of the 2026-09-10 balance read) |
| Ledger known − platform completed |
-14.00 (ledger misses 2 Seedance jobs and a few charged NBP jobs it recorded as Unlimited; the platform export is the number to publish) |
| Jobs in the project |
273 (78 completed Seedance, 124 completed NBP, 16 Soul Cinema at 0) vs project page 205 generations |
Refunded / failed jobs recorded (0 credits kept):
- 5A 7: 6 s test of v17 (shots/5A/tests/v17_test6s_fence.txt): L1 wording + L2 led turn + v2 opaque sheet, Blender ref
- plate_car_s6_green 1: job 00d023e0 status failed after ~20 min in_progress (queued ~4 min first); tile: Failed / Credits refunded; n
- 1A-start rebuild-v3: UI NSFW / Restricted content detected / Credits refunded. No output image. Submitted Unlimited so no debit/ref
- 1B sync-edit-v1: UI Input may contain a real person or public figure; Credits refunded. Source was generatedHiggsfield1B not re
- 4D laugh-rock-A: Script [laughs] alone rejected by platform (job 4cd69b32 status failed). Price read 0.15 before the click; ref
A.3 Cash, local compute, labour
| Category |
Value |
Source |
| Cash |
one Ultra plan month; the price paid was not recorded in the ledgers → unknown here; the list price of that plan as of 2026-09-22 is in A.5; no top-up (Director rule) |
HIGGSFIELD-PLAN row 0.10; Director rules |
| Local compute |
brain (2× RTX 3090): Wan pass Sep 8–10 (59 takes, one GPU died), MusicGen score Sep 16; hours not metered → unknown |
BRAIN-PASS-2026-09-08.md, SCORE-PLAN.md |
| Labour |
Director review rounds and agent sessions; not metered → unknown; the git log (Aug 13 → Sep 16, ~570 commits) is the only trace |
git log |
A.4 The Chapter 6 worksheet (v5: Chapter C), filled with HALFWAY
| Row |
HALFWAY value |
How derived |
| Cards in the shotlist |
39 shot families received at least one paid video job (masters and tests included) |
phase3 ledger, Seedance jobs grouped by shot id |
| Hero video jobs |
76 |
unique charged Seedance jobs |
| Retake share |
18 of 39 families had ≥2 jobs = 46% |
same |
| Test / stress / proof video jobs |
12 jobs, 398 credits |
note or settings mention test/stress/proof/arm |
| Seconds bought (parsed) |
466 s over 58 jobs; all 76 jobs ≈ 604 s at 4.5/s |
settings field; credits ÷ rate for the rest |
| Usable generated seconds in the final cut |
174.2 s |
CUT33 manifest, excluding title/credits/packshot |
| Trim loss |
1 − 174/604 ≈ 71% of bought seconds not in the film |
the two rows above; includes tests and rejected takes |
| Image jobs |
16 charged NBP + 161 unpriced NBP rows + phase 2 57 |
ledgers |
| Audio jobs |
44 TTS + 2 voice change, 9.71 credits |
ledgers |
| Rewrite reserve actually used |
ring scene recut into one shot (6B-lift dropped), 7A2 removed, 5A far-earring and 5C stubble retakes, final 8A added |
build_cutNN docstrings, ledger decisions |
| Time |
not metered; Sep 10 → Sep 16 for phase 3 |
git log |
| Stop threshold |
never written down before the first spend; the closest was the Director's 'no top-up' rule |
Director rules |
Validation: the worksheet rows above reproduce the A.1 video total by construction (same rows). What the worksheet could not have predicted in advance: the 71 % trim loss and the 46 % retake share. Those two numbers are the point of the appendix.
Read 2026-09-22T20:39Z to 20:55Z from each public pricing page, signed out (the receipt is plan-prices-2026-09-22.json beside this file). Prices exclude tax; every page says so or is silent. Ours was made on Higgsfield because the festival lived there; nothing in the process needs it. Two of the four are Chinese; both keep their plan tables behind a login, so only what a signed-out page shows is here, and the rest is unknown, not estimated. Prices change; re-read before you budget (Chapter 6).
| Platform |
Plan |
Credits / month |
USD / month, monthly |
USD / month, billed annually |
Page note |
| Higgsfield |
Starter |
270 |
19 |
19 |
page: 'No difference compared to monthly'; '~15 Seedance 2.0 Fast videos' |
| Higgsfield |
Plus |
1,200 |
59 |
47 |
'~53 Seedance 2.0 videos' |
| Higgsfield |
Ultra (3,000 tier; 6,000 and 9,000 tiers exist, not read) |
3,000 |
129 |
99 |
'~133 Seedance 2.0 videos'; the plan HALFWAY was made on |
| Runway |
Standard |
625 |
15 |
12 |
|
| Runway |
Pro |
2,250 |
35 |
28 |
|
| Runway |
Max |
9,500 |
95 |
76 |
credits roll over one month |
| Kling AI |
Standard |
660 |
10 (then 8.8 after a 12 % monthly discount; first month 6.99) |
not read |
page: '100 Credits = $1.06' |
| Kling AI |
Pro |
3,000 |
37 (then 32.56 after a 12 % monthly discount; first month 25.99) |
not read |
'100 Credits = $0.87' |
| Kling AI |
Premier |
8,000 |
92 (then 80.96 after a 12 % monthly discount; first month 64.99) |
not read |
'100 Credits = $0.81' |
| Kling AI |
Ultra |
26,000 |
180 (then 159.99 after a 12 % monthly discount; first month 127.99) |
not read |
'100 Credits = $0.49' |
| Jimeng (即梦) / Dreamina |
plans behind login |
unknown |
unknown |
unknown |
signed-out page shows only: "中秋礼遇 |
| Hailuo (海螺) / MiniMax |
plans behind login |
unknown |
unknown |
unknown |
signed-out page shows only: "From $9.99/mo" |
Cost of one generated second, where a page gives both numbers. Dollars per second = (USD per month, monthly) ÷ (credits per month) × (credits per second of the named job). Only rows whose two inputs are on the page or in our ledger are computed; resolution and model differ across rows, so this compares what each platform charges, not what you get.
| Platform, plan |
Job |
Credits / s |
USD / credit |
USD / s |
Source of credits / s |
| Higgsfield, Ultra |
Seedance 2.0, 720p, 8 s |
4.5 |
129 ÷ 3,000 = 0.0430 |
0.193 |
GENERATE button read 2026-09-10 (HIGGSFIELD-PLAN-2026-09-10.md:88), not on today's pricing page |
| Runway, Pro |
Gen-4.5, 5 s |
12 |
35 ÷ 2,250 = 0.0156 |
0.187 |
compare table on the page |
| Runway, Pro |
Seedance 2.0 Pro 1080p, 4 s |
40 |
35 ÷ 2,250 = 0.0156 |
0.622 |
compare table on the page |
| Runway, Pro |
Seedance 2.0 Fast, 4 s |
29 |
35 ÷ 2,250 = 0.0156 |
0.451 |
compare table on the page |
| Kling AI |
any video |
unknown |
— |
unknown |
not on the membership page; shown at the generate button after sign-in |
| Jimeng (即梦) / Dreamina |
Seedance 2.5 720p, promotional first-month floor |
not read |
not read |
¥0.28 / s (CNY, promotional, first month) |
banner, signed out; the plan table needs a Chinese login and was not read |