Appendix B — Capability matrix and tool inventory
Status: DRAFT 1 (2026-09-21), DESIGN v6 §7, §12. Column "verified on" is the date of a ledger row or file that shows the capability in use on HALFWAY; "reproduced on another tool" is empty by decision: the §7 test was not run (Director, 2026-09-22).
B.1 Capabilities the process depends on
| Capability | Required? | We used (brand) | Verified on (evidence) | Fallback when absent | Reproduced on another tool |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Identity from ordered reference images | required | Nano Banana Pro, Seedance 2.0 image references | 2026-09-11 (ledger row 1, tags @char_HW_Crystal_hairup_v1 …); 2026-09-16 (row 588, refs uploaded into project, price read 2) |
one hero still per shot as start frame + text identity block + face-check sentence; more stress takes | — |
| Start frame from an in-project still | required for dialogue shots | Seedance Start Frame | 2026-09-13 (row 272: "tile → Turn to video → Use as → Start Frame"); LESSONS.md L7 take 10, 2.7 px drift | image-to-video on any tool; else shorter shots, cut on action | — |
| Motion reference video | optional | Seedance video input | 2026-09-16 (rows 571–572, job 26d72daa, 5C stubble retake) | describe the motion beat; tier budget covers the retake | — |
| Audio reference conditioning | optional | Seedance audio input | 2026-09-14 (rows 393–395, 1B proof: conditions only, timing not honoured; no controlled comparison) | generate silent, place the line in the edit, accept per DESIGN §6 sync rule | — |
| Dialogue sync acceptance | required (some path) | placement by window + Director ear/eye; Sync Lipsync 3 prepared, declined | 2026-09-16 (rows 499, 504, 511) | dedicated lip-sync tool, coverage rewrite, or shorter line | — |
| Price visible before spend | required | Cinema Studio composer button, zoom-read | every job row ("button read 30 struck → 23", row 589) | compute from the rate card, ledger as computed not read | — |
| Batch TTS, one file per line, tone tags | required | ElevenLabs v3 in Higgsfield (Naomi, Holden) | 2026-09-12 (row 65, 0.15 per line); AUDIO-PLAN.md:61–72 | any per-line TTS; tone by rewording | — |
| Voice change keeping timing | optional | Higgsfield Voice Change | 2026-09-16 (rows 540, 557; 0.1/s rounded up) | re-record with the target voice and re-cut | — |
| AI score | required (some AI music source) | MusicGen large on a private GPU | 2026-09-16 (rows 576–578, 593; cues uploaded, assets 266 → 271) | hosted AI music tool; no GPU on the required path | — |
| Read a take: strips, crops, transcript, loudness | required | ffmpeg 9, whisper.cpp 1.9.1, Pillow, numpy | every read row; tools/media.sh | same, free everywhere | — |
| Assembly from a manifest, never overwrite | required | ffmpeg build script per cut | every cut row; templates/build_cut.py tested 2026-09-21 (240/240) | any NLE with a written shot table and per-cut folders | — |
| Ledger | required | csv + git, Python csv.writer | production/phase3/ledger.csv (606 rows at 2026-09-21) | spreadsheet with the same columns | — |
| Jobs and balance readable from the account | strongly recommended | platform jobs API and user API | 2026-09-16 (rows 550, 603: balance and 273-job export) | the account page, read by hand, after every job | — |
B.2 What was not on the required path
- A private GPU. Used for the local pre-pass (Chapter 1, Case 1-A) and the score (Chapter 14). Both have hosted fallbacks. The GPU died on the first day of use.
- A dedicated lip-sync tool. Prepared, never submitted (row 504), declined by the Director (row 511). Not shown as incapable.
- An NLE. Never used. All cuts were scripted.
B.3 Tool inventory as run (moved from Chapter 1 draft 1)
Versions read 2026-09-21 on the production machine.
| Tool | Version | What it did |
|---|---|---|
| ffmpeg / ffprobe | 9.0.1 (Homebrew); no drawtext filter in this build |
every trim, grade, sheet, strip, loudness read, assembly, full decode |
whisper.cpp whisper-cli |
1.9.1, model ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin (1.62 GB) |
transcripts; 10 s clip in 1.8 s wall on this Mac |
| Python | 3.9.6, Pillow 11.3.0, numpy 2.0.2 | build scripts, caption PNGs, RMS windows, ledger rows, Appendix A |
| git | 2.54.0 | history of every text file |
| Agent | Claude Code with a Chrome extension driving the Director's signed-in browser; Codex for adversarial passes | operator |
tools/media.sh commands used: probe, frames, sheet, first, firstsec, audio, loudness [--target --tol --peak], transcribe <file> <lang>, img [--luma-min …]. Two properties: a bare call only reports and never claims a pass; every failure exits non-zero with a sentence. One known defect, kept as a teaching case (Chapter 6): firstsec printed PASS on an empty mask (LESSONS.md:128).
B.4 Reproducibility test (DESIGN §7): NOT RUN, by decision
One representative scene of a fresh story through every mandatory stage on a clean laptop with no GPU and none of our private skills: bible → planning card → final prompt → fenced generation → read → line placed and sync-accepted → assembled → hosted AI score under it → exported and decoded. The Director decided on 2026-09-22 not to run it. The "reproduced on another tool" column therefore stays empty, Chapters 9–15 carry the status "verified on one tool", and the first learner on another platform is the test; their Chapter 16 forms are the result.