Chapter 12 — Scale to the whole film
Status: DRAFT 1 (2026-09-21), DESIGN v6 §4. Sources: production/phase3/SHOOT-ORDER.md; docs/artifacts/SPEND-QUEUE.md; PRODUCTION.md:997–1017 (the ladder); production/phase3/ledger.csv rows 414–465, 499–511.
12.0 Objective
Given one assembled scene, you can set a shoot order for the rest, run the spend loop and the ledger at speed without losing a row, apply the escalation ladder when a shot will not come, and accept sync per shot.
12.1 What you are deciding
Order, pace, and when to stop. The same loop as Chapter 11, six more times, under a clock. Three decisions: which scene next (by confidence and by what the cut is missing, not by story order); how many cards per sitting the ledger can keep up with; and the ladder, written down before you need it, so a card on its third take does not quietly become a card on its eighth.
12.2 How we did it
Order by confidence. The shoot order (SHOOT-ORDER.md:3–12) put scene 6 first, "turn of the film, all stills in hand", then 5, 4, 2, 1, 3, 7. One take per card, 720p, sound off on line cards, with a gate per scene: "first-second strip + identity read on every take before the next scene's clicks" (:4). Cards whose still had not passed were deferred inside their scene ("5C once its still passes").
A queue, not a plan. "One line per generation. Nothing is generated until its line says approved in the Director's own edit or message. A retake is a new line" (SPEND-QUEUE.md:3–5). Prices were observed and dated on the queue (:25–30), with the honest note "The second, lower figure on the button was not explained by the UI."
The deadline week. The ledger's row count by date, from a parse of the file (not a figure any row states): 256 rows on 2026-09-13, 136 on the 14th. The night of the 14th: CUT05 exported and rejected (rows 414–418: "five-second readable opening text, lip sync fixes, remove 4M/5M"), then seven retakes fenced and bought in three hours (rows 425–444: a 2-credit still, a 54-credit 12 s shot, 45, 18, 27, 2, 54), the Director's performance benchmark (row 446), CUT08 at 23:58 (row 460: 205.4 s, 4929 frames, full decode, watermark and packshot, "no score"), the public post at 00:00 (row 461). The submitted file was then frozen: every later cut row says "Submitted CUT08 unchanged".
The ladder (PRODUCTION.md:1005–1009). Rung 1, "1–5 takes, same fault": one line changed, logged. Rung 2, "6–15 takes": change the shot. Rung 3, ~20 takes: "Suspect the asset, not the prompt." Rung 4: "Stop generating. Escalate to the Director as a creative decision." Rung 5, the Director's call: "Rewrite the beat, cover it another way, or cut it — and check the cut against the statement." And: "Rung 5 is the one that is usually missing" (:1011). The take counts on the rungs are the reference production's; v6 fixes the budget per card by tier instead (DESIGN §6), so rung 4 fires when the budget is spent, not at twenty.
Sync per shot. After Chapter 11's 4C, each spoken shot got its own decision: placement inside the mouth window, then the Director's playback. A lip-sync tool was set up once with the audio and video in place and never submitted (row 504); the Director's ruling closed it: "4C keep v1 (+0.5 s), no Sync3" (row 511).
12.3 Case 12-A — the week the ledger was the film
- What I saw: 392 ledger rows in two days, seven video retakes in one night, and a film submitted with its build note reading "residual formal Crystal lines remain; no final Director approval or submission receipt" (row 460). The 4G card was rejected by the Director at 01:05 (SHOOT-ORDER.md:27), the 1D audio at the same minute (:33), and 7A came back "OFF-CARD — model ignored the start frame" (:36). The entry went in with those.
- Why I think so: the animatic had been silent and off-platform (Chapter 10), the stress test had been three takes of one hero (Chapter 9), and the performance review came after the third assembly (Chapter 8). Every gate skipped early was paid for in the last 48 hours at video prices, and the ledger kept up only because the agent wrote the rows.
- What I changed: nothing in the week; the film shipped. In the book: W3 and W4 before any scene, and this chapter's rule that a scene is not started until the previous one is assembled and watched.
- Would this happen on your tool? It happens on any tool with a deadline. The ledger is what let us know afterwards what it had cost; that is its floor, not its purpose.
12.4 Do it with your tools
The ledger under load: the agent writes every row from the read, never from the plan (Case 0-A); the queued row is written before the read row exists; a missed row is a correction row later, never an edit. If your agent cannot append while it drives the browser, run two agents: one clicks, one writes.
12.5 Your turn
Time cap: as long as the sheet allows; one scene per sitting. Spend: the remaining cards × tier budget.
- Shoot order: scenes by confidence (stills passed, lines approved) and by what the assembled cut most needs; the turn shot of each scene first.
- Per scene: the Chapter 11 loop, then assemble and watch adjacent pairs before the next scene's first credit.
- Ladder card: before the first retake, write the ladder with your tier budgets on it and tape it to the wall. Rung 4 is the budget; rung 5 is yours, and it includes cutting the beat.
- Sync per shot: record the decision and its path for every spoken shot; a shot with no decision is unverified.
- Stop threshold: when the ledger's running total crosses it, stop, assemble what exists, and decide with the second reader what the film is without the missing cards before buying another.
12.6 Gate
Each line needs valid evidence per DESIGN §5; outcomes are pass / fail / unverified, and unverified blocks.
- Every scene assembled in its own cut folder before the next scene's first credit (evidence: cut timestamps against job timestamps).
- Every job has its queued and read rows; corrections are rows (evidence: ledger; a script can check the pairs).
- No card's take count exceeds its tier budget; a card whose budget is spent has a rung-4 stop row and a rung-5 decision row (rewrite, cover another way, or cut), or a replacement card with its own budget (evidence: ledger).
- Every spoken shot has a sync decision with its path (evidence: the case or notes lines).
- The running total against the stop threshold is in the ledger after every scene (evidence: the rows).
- Performance task: 7A is a 9 s silent turn-scene card (tier: turn, budget 3), one take so far, which came back "OFF-CARD — model ignored the start frame" (SHOOT-ORDER.md:36). Write which rung it is on, what the second take changes (a shape change or the one permitted seed retake, and why), and what happens if the third take also ignores the start frame (evidence: the three lines).
Pass example from HALFWAY: the shoot order's per-scene gate, strip and identity read before the next scene's clicks. Fail example: the night of 2026-09-14, seven retakes in three hours with the animatic and stress gates still open.