Appendix E — The rules, with every source
Status: DRAFT 1 (2026-09-21), DESIGN v6 §6, §12. E.1 is the full standing-rules table that Chapter 0 draft 1 carried and v6 distributed across chapters; E.2 is the rule hierarchy; E.3 the reconciled rules with their source lines; E.4 the instructor-form cases for the rules whose attribution was established.
E.1 The nine standing rules the agent worked under, and where each lands in the book
Sources: production/phase3/HANDOVER-CODEX-2026-09-14.md:22–38 ("Hard rules (do not break, ever)"); the takeover brief of 2026-09-15; ledger rows of 2026-09-16.
| # | Rule | Source line | Why it exists | Chapter |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | The Director approves every spend; one job per approved decision; report after every job and read | takeover brief; ledger rows 585–594 (every spend preceded by a Director call) | an unsupervised agent will, in good faith, buy a fourth take of a shot the Director would cut | 0 |
| 2 | Ledger every job, every read, every decision; append only | HANDOVER:36 "Ledger every job and every decision (format §7)" | without it the balance is a guess; ours ended 14 credits short of the platform's export and the gap was findable only because the rows existed (Appendix A §A.2) | 0 |
| 3 | Numbers only after the read; never fabricate a number | HANDOVER:30–31 "Never fabricate numbers. Every credit figure is the price read from the GENERATE button before the click" | numbers are what the Director decides on; Case 0-A | 0 |
| 4 | Never delete or overwrite | HANDOVER:29 "Never delete anything in the Higgsfield project or the repo. Even if asked. Say so." | a fix that overwrites the approved version destroys the thing that was approved; 33 cuts still exist | 1 |
| 5 | Nothing generated off-platform enters the project as asset, reference or first frame; audio may be made anywhere if uploaded into the project | HANDOVER:24–26 | festival compliance (DELIVERY-SHEET.md:37–38); the storyboard and animatic stayed outside | 2 |
| 6 | Never attach a real person's footage or voice to a generation | HANDOVER:27–28 "The Director's Canon clips of real actors are NEVER attached to any generation (identity leak, LESSONS L4)"; AUDIO-PLAN.md:29 | festival rule (DELIVERY-SHEET.md:29) and a permanent identity leak (LESSONS.md:45) | 2 |
| 7 | Fence before spend; read the price at the button; one click; verify the job exists before any second click | HANDOVER:32–33 "One click per job. Verify a 'Generating' tile or a new job in the API before any second click. A re-click once cost 27 credits (duplicate job)." | ledger rows 3, 217, 225 (Chapter 6) | 6 |
| 8 | Only the Director's signed-in browser; never a sign-in by the agent; never the Director's own working tab | HANDOVER:34–35 | accounts and sessions are the Director's | 6 |
| 9 | Report format WHAT I READ / REMAINING ISSUES / NEXT ACTION; a contact sheet is not playback, a waveform is not lip-sync, a different angle is not a different person | CLAUDE-TAKEOVER-2026-09-15.md; DIRECTOR-REJECTIONS.md:9 | judgments the evidence cannot support are the failure the report format prevents | 0, 16 |
The decision table (who decides what), from PRODUCTION.md §1.5, as Chapter 0 draft 1 carried it:
| Decision | Owner | Explicitly not decided by |
|---|---|---|
| What the film is about; which scenes survive the cut | Director | any gate |
| Whether a character reads as the person the story needs | Director | conformance checks on the sheet |
| Whether a world feels like the place | Director | palette sampling |
| Which take is the take | Director | any automated check |
| When a shot is abandoned, rewritten, or cut | Director | the retake rule alone |
| Picture lock; final delivery | Director | — |
| Whether a sheet meets spec | process + scripts | — |
| Whether runtime and reference budgets hold | arithmetic | — |
| Whether prompts carry stale or duplicated tags | prompt auditor | — |
| Whether identity, geography or palette drifted | scripts + review | — |
E.2 Rule hierarchy (DESIGN §6)
| Origin | Examples | Status in the book |
|---|---|---|
| Inherited from the reference feature (PRODUCTION.md) | "no shot grown from a still"; 10-of-10 stress; "after 15–20 generations change the shot"; master card first | advice, cited as inherited; "master first" replaced by "turn shot first" on the director review |
| Superseded by our own measurement | start frames (LESSONS.md:48, L7) | resolved rule below |
| Measured on one model only | the shape rule for second takes (BRAIN-PASS-2026-09-08.md §Learnings) | default rule, labelled "measured on one model, transfer unverified" |
| Tool-specific finding | two-lead face swap (LESSONS.md:67); [laughs] alone rejected (ledger row 527); audio-reference timing (LESSONS.md:136) |
flagged "verify on your tool" |
| Current learner gate | the reconciled rules | checklist lines |
E.3 Reconciled rules with source lines
- Start frames. Never seed a shot from the previous clip's last frame (PRODUCTION.md, inherited). A purpose-made frame-zero still generated in the same project from the same references may be the Start Frame; the returned frame zero is compared with the still before the take counts. Sources: LESSONS.md:48 ("An opening pose is pinned with a first frame, not with words"), :69–75 (take 10, 2.7 px drift, "Start frames are now standard for every card with a held opening").
- Takes per card. Tier budget (turn 3, dialogue single 2, insert 1) set in Chapter 6. Default second take is a shape change; seed retake for turn shots only, once. Sources: ROUND18-RULES.md:23–25 ("two takes hard cap; a retake only when the prompt changes shape, never to polish detail"); BRAIN-PASS-2026-09-08.md §Learnings ("thirteen second takes scored the same as the first"; "Every improvement came from a change in the shape of the prompt"); Appendix A (retake share 46 %); PRODUCTION.md:1005–1009 (the ladder), :1011 ("Rung 5 is the one that is usually missing").
- Dialogue synchronisation. Window alignment on a 24 fps strip is a candidate pass only; acceptance by ear and eye on playback by the named owner; three paths when a tool cannot deliver. Sources: ledger rows 499 ("none is a syllable pass"), 504 (Sync Lipsync 3 prepared, no submission), 511 ("4C keep v1 (+0.5 s), no Sync3"); DIRECTOR-REJECTIONS.md:7, :14.
- Performance acceptance. By ear against the intention line, separately from voice identity and from sync. Source: DIRECTOR-REJECTIONS.md:6 ("Approval of Naomi/Holden as voice identities is not approval of each delivery").
- Audio references condition, they do not time. Sources: LESSONS.md:136 ("Attached audio plus timestamp prose did not establish exact timing … no controlled comparison exists"); 1B-proof-review/CLAUDE-VERDICT.md:27, :29.
- Blocking references are for hand positions only, never first frames, never identity. Source: ROUND18-RULES.md:21 (R8).
- The line. Each scene's map fixes the axis and each character's side; every single states its eyeline; a cut that crosses without a neutral shot is a defect. Source: v6 addition on the director review (REVIEW-DIRECTOR-2026-09-21.md finding 5); the failure it addresses: DIRECTOR-REJECTIONS.md:8.
- Two-lead stills need the faces first and last. Source: LESSONS.md:67.
- Prop scale lives in the words and the sheet's proportions; never "plain sight" for something the story needs found. Source: LESSONS.md:49 (L8).
- Reference video shorter than the generation. Source: LESSONS.md:46 (L5).
- A real person in any reference leaks identity. Source: LESSONS.md:45 (L4).
E.4 Instructor-form cases (attribution established)
Start frames (L7)
- Observation: 5A take 9, arms at sides then raised and clasped over 0–0.7 s, 30 px sway, against a card saying no movement (LESSONS.md:48).
- Attribution: text and a static reference clip do not fix the model's first second; every take settled over 0.3–0.7 s.
- Controlled comparison: yes. Take 10, same card, frame-zero still as start frame: 2.7 px drift against 60 px (LESSONS.md:70–71).
- Remedy: frame-zero still per held-opening card; firstsec gate.
- Residual uncertainty: none on this tool.
- Transfer limit: tool-specific mechanism (Start Frame), general rule (pin poses with an image).
Two-lead face swap (second L9) - Observation: 8 of the first 20 two-lead stills with both faces replaced by a Caucasian pair; singles and hands never (LESSONS.md:67). - Attribution: composition prior over named identity on two-person frames. - Controlled comparison: partial. Reference order and face-check sentence added; held on six cards; 5C failed twice with the tail line alone and held with the opening line added. No arm with the old order re-run after the fix. - Remedy: faces first and last. - Residual uncertainty: which of the two changes carried the fix. - Transfer limit: tool-specific; verify on yours.
The ledger gap - Observation: ledger known total 2795.71 against platform export 2809.71 (Appendix A §A.2). - Attribution: two video jobs and a few charged image jobs recorded as unlimited; found by the reconciliation script against the paginated jobs export. - Controlled comparison: not applicable. - Remedy: the platform's number is published; the ledger's row schema gained a job id column. - Residual uncertainty: 12 credits of phase-2 images without a figure, marked unknown. - Transfer limit: general.
The number written before the read (Case 0-A): see Chapter 0; attribution established by the two rows.
The empty-mask PASS (Case 6-A): see Chapter 6; attribution established by tools/media.sh:184, :193 and LESSONS.md:128.