Chapter 3 — Story to shootable script
Status: DRAFT 1 (2026-09-21), DESIGN v6 §4, §10. Sources: docs/stories/GRADER.md, CANDIDATES.md, FORTY-MINUTES.md, KIN.md, HALFWAY-BEATS.md; docs/artifacts/HALFWAY-SCREENPLAY.md; PRODUCTION.md:241–273.
3.0 Objective
Given a premise, you can produce the six greenlight artefacts (premise line, statement, beat sheet, cut list, screenplay with final dialogue, delivery sheet) and run a cold-reader test on the turn.
3.1 What you are deciding
For a film under five minutes, "the script is the film, so it gets a phase" (PRODUCTION.md:241), and "a 5-minute film supports one turn, not three" (:245). You are deciding what that one turn is, in a form that can be shot: every line final, every beat a change in value, every scene owned by one character, and a written list of what is not in the film so it cannot creep back in during breakdown.
The six artefacts, in order (PRODUCTION.md:248–266): the premise line; the statement ("distinct from what happens in it"); the beat sheet (6–8 beats, one per scene, naming whose scene, what changes, value start and end); the cut list; the screenplay with final dialogue; the delivery sheet (Chapter 2, so it already exists). "A beat sheet is not a script and cannot be shot from: voice blocks, lip timing and the 15–20 line budget all derive from final lines" (:262).
3.2 How we did it
Kill premises early, in sentences. Our grader (GRADER.md) is "a rubric for killing premises early"; "every gate below exists because a candidate died of it" (:3–4). Its one rule of form: "Gates are answered in a written sentence, never a tick" (:16), because a candidate once passed a gate by checkmark and died when the question was asked aloud. "If the sentence cannot be written, the gate has failed."
DESIGN §10 splits our grader three ways. Transferable, always: the premise line fits one sentence; the statement is distinct from the plot; every beat changes a value; the turn survives a cold reader. Conditional, applied when the story has the element and otherwise written "N/A, because…": rule integrity (who enforces a prohibition and why it serves them) and livelihood (who pays her). Ours, optional, shown so you can adopt or refuse them (GRADER.md:22–29 has the wording):
| Our gate | The question | Must produce |
|---|---|---|
| Premise consent | does the ending require the audience to grant a contested moral claim? | a no (we required it; you may not) |
| Motive is personal | "would this specific woman do this if it meant nothing and nobody ever knew?" | "a want, not a significance" (:62) |
| Physical and factual coherence | does it survive "five seconds of its own physics"; are real-institution rules checked against a source? | a cited source per real-world rule |
| Cold-watch cost | "can a viewer name what she lost after one watch?" | the scene where the cost is legible |
The rest of our grader is taste, shown as ours: a scored panel with a bias it names itself: "Read the score as fitness for this pipeline, not as quality" (:105); "the rubric systematically favours small, cheap, low-risk films" (:103).
HALFWAY's six. Premise line and statement are in the front matter. The beat sheet (HALFWAY-BEATS.md:71–87) has six beats, one per scene, each with an owner and a value move ("− → 0", "+ → −"). The line allocation is a ceiling: twenty lines, Rock 9, Crystal 11, "None spare — the ceiling is reached" (:113–117). The cut list (:156–171) names what is not in the film so it cannot return: his wife and home ("One lit phone and one gold band"), any line containing married, wife, ring said by anyone else, why he stops ("No line, no look to camera, no flashback"), the hotel, a coda. The screenplay's standing rules (HALFWAY-SCREENPLAY.md:84–101): one speaker and one line per clip; one second of silence after every line; "Nobody kisses anybody."
Cold readers. Before the shotlist was approved, two blind readers were given the storyboard and "the Director ruled five fixes" (HALFWAY-SHOTLIST.md:43–44). One line was rewritten because a cold reader found it ambiguous (DIALOGUE-2026-09-05.md:84).
3.3 Case 3-A — two stories that died on paper
- What I saw: KIN, the first story, fully designed, six scenes, ~14 of 20 lines. Killed at premise consent: "the ending requires the audience to accept that relinquishing the child is the loving act. Contested premise" (CANDIDATES.md:77–83). Its rule had no enforcer: "A prohibition with no mechanism is a mood, not a law" (:133). FORTY MINUTES, shelved 2026-08-19: "Rejected by the Director as too trivial" (FORTY-MINUTES.md:380); "a film whose central event is a woman drinking a glass of juice, wrapped in eight gates of scaffolding that made it defensible without making it worth watching" (:386–390).
- Why I think so: the first failed a gate a second reader could see and the author could not ("Codex caught KIN's backwards law when in-session review could not", GRADER.md:112). The second passed every gate and was still nothing; "The scaffolding held. The event was too small to carry it." The grader was then given a dimension for the size of the event.
- What I changed: two things in this book. Every gate is a sentence, never a tick. And the cold reader is a person, not the author, and the question is "what happened at the turn?", not "does this pass?"
- Would this happen on your tool? It has nothing to do with tools. Both deaths cost zero credits, which is the point of doing this chapter before Chapter 9.
3.4 Do it with your tools
An agent is a good grader and a bad author. Use it to ask the gate questions and refuse a tick; use a second model or the second reader to read cold. Do not let it write your lines: the Director's benchmark lines in Chapter 8 were the ones with a want in them, and wants come from you.
3.5 Your turn
Time cap: one week of evenings. Spend: none.
- Write three premise lines, one sentence each. Run the four transferable gates on each, in sentences, then whichever of our optional gates you adopt (write down which, and why). Kill by sentence. Keep one.
- The statement, one or two sentences, distinct from the plot. Test: it decides an ambiguous shot. Ours: "nothing in the cut may make her wounded, and nothing may make him admirable" (HALFWAY-BEATS.md:33–34).
- The beat sheet: six to eight rows (C.9), one per scene, an owner, a value move, a location. Mark the turn: one beat, one moment.
- The cut list: what is not in the film. Ten items minimum.
- The screenplay: every line final; count them; set a ceiling (ours 20) and reach it, not exceed it; one speaker per clip; a second of silence after each line.
- ★ Cold read. Give the screenplay to the second reader. Ask: what happened at the turn? Who are the two people? Write their answers down verbatim. If the turn they retell is not yours, the script goes back to step 3.
3.6 Gate (W1 — Greenlight)
Each line needs valid evidence per DESIGN §5; outcomes are pass / fail / unverified, and unverified blocks.
- Six artefacts exist (evidence: the files).
- Every gate question is answered in a sentence; killed premises are kept with their killing sentence (evidence: the grader file).
- Every beat changes a value and has one owner (evidence: the beat sheet; the judgment is yours).
- The line count is at or under the ceiling (evidence: the count).
- ★ A cold reader retold the turn correctly (evidence: their words, verbatim, initialled).
- Performance task: take one of our killed premises (KIN, CANDIDATES.md:77) and, under our premise-consent gate, write the sentence that kills it in your own words, then the sentence that would have saved it; then say whether you adopt that gate for your film and why (evidence: the three sentences).
Pass example from HALFWAY: the beat sheet's turn, "Light two, beat 5. Tightest size in the film, longest hold: her face doing nothing, then the small downward smile" (HALFWAY-BEATS.md:91–93), which two blind readers retold. Fail example: FORTY MINUTES, every gate passed, the Director's one word "trivial".